Saturday, 14 November 2026

Neither God the Father nor Jesus Christ can make anybody wholly-good

I just state this here as something that I only recently realized explicitly, and which seems important. 

That, in all of scripture, there is no instance of the God of the Old Testament, or Jesus Christ in the New Testament, making somebody wholly-good - for example by divine creation, or by a miracle. 


This strikes me as evidence that this cannot be done.

And this, in turn, seems to have implications for understanding the scope and nature and possibilities of reality. 

For example; the necessity for Jesus Christ, and his making possible post-mortal resurrection to Heaven - is exactly that this was the way (presumably the only way?) that Men could be made wholly-good. 

**


Note: An exception, for some Eastern and Western Catholics (and not derived from explicit scripture), and apparently developing from the early 300s AD; may be Mary the mother of Jesus. Mary has sometimes been regarded as uniquely wholly-good from her conception: ie the assertion that Mary was created free from all sin. 

While I have great sympathy with "Mariolatry", and believe its advent did Christianity and people significant good overall; nonetheless; nonetheless a belief in Mary's absolute goodness seems - Very Obviously - to create stark and lethal contradictions for Christianity+. 

Because if Mary could be created perfect before Jesus; then there was no necessity, no qualitative requirement, for Jesus. 

In other words; if God could make an immaculate Mary; presumably God could have populated this world entirely with immaculate persons, each as-good-as Mary*. There would thus be no need for salvation, no need for Jesus.   


* The assumption would then be that such a God "could" have done this, but evidently did not - raising the killer question of "why not?". 

+ I therefore distinguish between the spiritual benefits of a veneration of Mary; and the theological rationalization of this veneration. 

4 comments:

  1. What about that OT guy who “walked with God” was carried straight up to heaven? The main justification for assuming that everyone sinned that I know of is Paul saying “All have sinned,” which of course isn’t literally true if Jesus did not sin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Mia - Same applies wrt what I said with Mary.

    My assumption is that Christian theologians have (over a looong time) confused themselves so very deeply by their own attempts to finesse (by complexification and paradox) the stark contradictions in their assumptions; that they have lost sight of the obvious consequences of two-step reasoning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I once came across in my studies of Pope St. John Paul II's Theology of the Body a quote from St. Maximilian Kolbe (a priest martyred in a concentration camp during the Second World War). In it, he makes the bold claim that Mary is the incarnation of the Holy Spirit. While Kolbe does add the caveat "in a sense," this is the most blatant expression I have found of a Catholic identifying Mary with the Godhead.

    Of course, this is precisely what the founder of Islam believed that Christianity taught. The funny thing is that, if we're being honest, he was correct. As you have written, Christianity is much more friendly to a dualistic, pagan conception of reality than Judaism or Islam despite the vehement protestations of Christian theologians. I don't know if you have seen it, but it has lately been a popular theme of certain Catholic YouTubers to point out the superficial similarities of Mormonism and Islam, as if the two could be conflated. Give me a break!

    As an aside, I will say that JPII's Theology of the Body is a brilliant recovery in a Catholic framework of the very heart of Christianity, namely the importance of our physical bodies. And has been very helpful to me personally. Your own writing on the subject has helped me to see that much of what I've learned from the Theology of the Body makes more sense through a dualistic lens.

    That said, it is a wonder to me that man who wrote it had a hand in the Second Vatican Council, effectively the destruction of the Catholic Church. I believe you once said once that the Church was organized such that reform of any kind, even positive, would destroy the whole. That seems accurate to me.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @FJ - The trouble is that hardly any of its critics has understood Mormon theology (least of all Mormons!); plus there are contradictions within the theology, and many more between the theology and the practice.

    But at a deep level of metaphysics, Mormonism is as different from the pure monotheism of Islam (or Judaism) as is possible; because Mormonism is the only explicitly pluralist and evolutionary Christian theology.

    But on the other hand, if its critics actually Did understand Mormon theology, they still would dislike it! So it hardly seems worth trying to correct them.

    From my POV, I am convinced that the stark contradictions in Christianity are no longer possible to ignore or forget. And no longer effective are the multiple abstractions and complex obfuscations that were used to cover them. It is not regarded as acceptable to draw a veil of "mystery" over incoherence.

    What used to "work", does not work any more.

    This has changed because in the past, Christianity was the default and most powerful system; but now atheistic materialism is default and official.

    Nowadays, extreme incoherence and self-contradiction is tolerated (or goes unnoticed, or is actively denied) in mainstream atheistic materialism - but not in any of its rivals; and especially not in Christianity.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are moderated. "Anonymous" comments are deleted without being read.