It is very common for me to read (serious, sincere, real) Christians advocating the goal of striving to extinguish our self-will, and aiming to make ouselves into obedient instruments of God's will.
The ideal is indeed sometimes expressed in terms of emptying our-selves, and the picture I get is of something like a living human puppet that is thinking, speaking and acting wholly in accordance to God's plans for it.
While, as I say, such Christians may be real Christians and may do good stuff; this is a bad way of conceptualizing how Christians should relate to God; and if taken seriously it will do harm.
This is bad for several reasons.
First is that it misrepresents God in an anti-Christian and incoherent way. Anti-Christian because it ignores the implications of the incarnation of Jesus Christ as a Man, and a mortal Man.
And more fundamentally, it makes no sense for a (good) God to create a vast diversity of individual Men each with free agency, if the highest usage of that agency is simply to negate itself.
This would be for God to create, and then to undo creation.
But also in practice the claim that one is acting in mere obedience to God's instruction has very frequently been used to cover-up and excuse selfish and sinful behaviour.
Now, at one level, this is just an inevitable consequence of the fact that all Men are sinners; but this particular sin is compounded by an intrinsic denial of responsibility that is itself reinforced by the ideal of passive oedience.
If one is acting in mere obedience to God and if this behaviour is required of Christians as their highest ideal; then this is a situation in which all responsibility for the action lies with God.
Thus; individual persons in this supposedly highest state of devotion and faith are not responsible for what they think, say, or do - or for what happens.
In other words, the ideal of passivity of will, and of behaving as a material instrument of God's spirit; forms a self-justifying in an inescapable cycle.
If not, then what?
Well, by my understanding, a properly Christian spirit and motivation behind the false conceptualization of self-negation and mere-obedience; is that we ought to act aligned-with, and in harmony with, God's will and the nature of divine creation.
Our will and self are supposed to be strong and individual; and added-to that of God.
**
NOTE ADDED. I should add a note on this concept of responsibility, or more exactly "spiritual responsibility" as William Wildblood terms it in a comment below.
I regard it as of extreme importance that Christians take responsibility for their faith and actions here-and-now.
Actually, this was always the case; but in the past most people were much less self-aware than now; so that this issue was much less obvious - and the malign nature and contradictions of mere obedience were less evident.
Of course; because of our nature and the nature of this world, mistakes and self-deceptions are inevitable, as is succumbing to evil. But this applies to institutions and theoir leaders just as much as (over even more than) to individual persons. The point is for us to be able to recognize and correct error.
Someone who takes personal spiritual responsibility for his decisions has no excuses, because he regards his own error is his own fault, his own choice. Therefore, I would argue that such a Christian should be more likely to recognize and correct error; than would someone else who has used his agency to suppress and subordinate his will to external guidance (as he understand that), in order passively to serve and obey.
It seems vital that people remove self-excuses on the lines of "I was just obeying orders". Even when the choice is to obey an order despite that order being judged to be wrong - e.g. because the consequences of disobedience to wrongness seem worse than obeying - then it ought to be clear that this still requires acknowledgement of the perceived wrongness and of personal responsibility for choosing to follow such instructions.
A Christian who chooses to "outsource" his spiritual decision-making, cannot allow this choice to remove his spiritual responsibility for the consequences.
Self-extinguishing is actually an evasion of spiritual responsibility. We are meant to be active co-creators with God not servants who just obey. These people confuse the self-centred egotistic will with the pure individual will which works with divine creation and is able to contribute to it in a positive manner.
ReplyDelete@William. Yes. I increasingly believe that this matter of personal responsibility is something that needs special emphasis here and now.
ReplyDeleteI've put a "note added" to this effect.
It seems to often come back to the loss of our understanding of transcendence. I hear all the time “Empty me of me, and fill me with You,” or “to have a Godly marriage you have wake up every day and KILL your self” and similar from well-meaning Christians, and these things are partly true. But without the understanding that we are put on a lower level first in order to gain necessary and beneficial experience and knowledge that we then take with us to a higher level but with changes (refinement, elevation, purification)…well, without that it’s just horrid! As you say- anti-Creation ergo anti-Christian. I try to have patience bc “transcendence” was meaningless gobbledegook to me for most of my life, but my patience can only extend so far bc while i can understand wanting to obliterate one’s own self for largely good reasons the flip side of that has to be also wanting to obliterate others- your spouse, your children. That’s so obviously monstrous, my patience quickly runs out.
ReplyDelete@Mia - I think that the motive behind that kind of unconsidered rhetoric is the desire to become a better person; indeed to be purged of All sin and become a wholly good person.
ReplyDeleteI guess this is based on the true insight that this cannot be done by just trying, because our motives are significantly sinful.
The only "answer" would then be to empty-out the corrupt human will and replace it with a pure divine will.
This may have appeal so long as you don't think about it too hard; but it is a fact that it has never actually happened to anyone, not even the Saints (who always insist on their own sinfulness).
Killing or emptying-out the-self as a way of solving the problem of sin, is analogous to killing people to prevent them sinning - or even better, that they aren't even born in the first place. It is double-negation, anti-life, anti-creation.
But my understanding is that Jesus never asked or expected people to be perfectly good, or even better. His scheme (thanks be!) is not for the salvation of the perfect, or even the "better" people, but for the salvation of everyone who wants and chooses it.
It seems a strange and shocking thing to say, even a dangerous thing; but there is a very strong sense in which real Christianity ultimately has *nothing* to do with self-improvement, or even the attempt at self-improvement (ie. nothing to do with the things that most devout Christians spend most of their time trying to do).
It is about what we want; not what we are like or what we can achieve.