Saturday, 6 September 2025

Is Everything a Total Fake?

It is an interesting and significant fact, that major-controlling institutions in our totalitarian Western society often tolerate - and indeed fund and publicise - books, TV, movies, and social commentary; the arguments of which categorically assert that Everything in public discourse is a Fake - and, in the most uncompromising versions - always has been a Fake, through history.

The expounded idea is that official and mass media narratives are (in general) pure illusion, based on nothing at all; an eggshell of false narrative enclosing a void of real life content. 

At the most extreme level, the "Everything a Fake" people seem to be saying that "nothing ever happened" - at least nothing that was said officially to have happened. They are suggesting that public discourse has always been pure illusion.  


With individual exceptions - this is not generally true, especially not as we go further back into eras in which the mass media and state propaganda systems were smaller and less effective.

I feel confident that "Everything has always been a Fake" is not true, from the big changes in increasing fakery that I have experienced through my lifespan, and by the obvious acceleration of such trends through the 1990s and into the 21st century. 

If Fakery has got so much worse in living memory, then clearly things were less faked in the past. 


Also, we know that Total Fakery isn't the norm from the huge efforts that The System invests to make things happen. 

This would not be the case if it was normal and expected to manufacture significant fakes from zilch. Important fakes aren't built on nothing, for the obvious reason that then they would be less effective

We all know that lies mixed with facts are much more convincing than complete fabrications. 
 

When fakery incorporates real aspects of actual events; fakes are far more difficult to disentangle and thereby disprove outright - hence far more convincing to the credulous and inattentive majority. 

What (in general) happened in the past was that underlying events were essentially real (albeit much more often contrived by the authorities than realized at the time); but the truth of reality was exaggerated, or twisted by fakery, in order to manipulate public opinion. 

The incremental trend (especially over the past several generations) was both for fakery to become more dominant; and for the underlying real events to become more top-down contrived. 


For instance, the 2020 Birdemic was very nearly a Total Fake; in that it was invented, planned, and implemented top-down - and some "evidential" aspects were Total Fakes (e.g. things that had not happen were theatrically staged and filmed). 

But as a total phenomenon; the Birdemic incorporated many real world actions and events - and the consequences of pseudo-therapeutic interventions (e.g. extra deaths caused by supposedly anti-Birdemic medico-social changes) - into its pre-determined narrative. 

Eventually; there resulted a hyper-complex and deliberately-confused mass of many inventions, illusions and lies - built-upon and mixed-with a few factual realities. 

Consequently; we know for sure that the official narratives are all false and deliberately misleading; but it can never be known what actually happened minus the Fakery. 


The lesson is that although some small things are indeed a Total Fake, most important lies will interweave real facts and events. 

Which does not, of course, mean that there is "some truth" in (for instance) the Birdemic, the CO2 Climate narrative, or the current top-down imposition of AI; because events and facts are not truth

We must learn to distinguish between facts and truth: facts only have meaning when interpreted by theory. 

Thus, when theory is false and dishonest, then "real facts" can only serve to sustain a false and dishonest understanding. 


In sum: all the major strategies of the global totalitarians are fundamentally and intentionally false - despite their not being total fakes; and despite whatever correct facts and real events are woven into them.

Total Fakery is not the real problem - which is why people are encouraged (officially!) to entertain the idea of Total Fakes at such length, and in such detail. 

It is intentional untruthfulness in service to evil intent, that is the real problem.         
 

8 comments:

  1. A lot of the time I just have a strong sense I'm being lied to from the insistence and repetition of the claims. They actually don't seem to have much finesse, often. Unless the finesse lies elsewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "I feel confident that "Everything has always been a Fake" is not true, from the big changes in increasing fakery that I have experienced through my lifespan, and by the obvious acceleration of such trends through the 1990s and into the 21st century "

    I agree. If you can't trust your own experiences and evaluations, what can you trust? That is the baseline. "Everything is fake" turns into an inverted "trust the experts" situation.

    While historical knowledge is secondary and not completely certain, it presents societies and values that are substantially different from our current one. And you don't even have to go back that far to see that. To say that it was all just a hall of mirrors undermines that and replaces it with nothing but cynicism.

    And also, "everything is fake" doesn't actually give people courage or fortitude as far as I can see. But people's own memories, knowledge of history, and evaluations of good and bad do.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For some reason this post brought to mind Jonathan Pageau -- I'm not sure why.

    Dr. Charlton, are you familiar with Pageau's work? If so, do you have an opinion on it?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Seems like the puppets of the Establishment also get confused very often. They get so caught up in it they forget how to breathe. "What's next? What's next? We gotta have something otherwise what are we even doing here?"

    ReplyDelete
  5. @NLR - yes indeed. I should probably have added emphasis that this is why I think the "everything is a total fake" is given so much publicity.

    For example, people high up in the totalitarian hierarchy will sometimes put out the "we all live in a simulation" trope.

    Not much could be more despair-inducing if taken seriously - which for Them is a desirable outcome.

    ReplyDelete
  6. @Stephen M - No, I don't know of JP or his work.

    ReplyDelete
  7. what i find more significant is that even when they tell the truth they are lying

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's not always easy to tell truth from fiction; although mostly what was done was suppression of some facts, promotion of other facts, and the insistence on favored interpretations. Only lately have complete fabrications become the norm.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are moderated. "Anonymous" comments are deleted without being read.