Monday, 28 July 2025

Pure Protestants and "Bare Salvation"

A serious problem that besets (what might be called) Pure Protestants, is the minimalist desire for Salvation-only - a life dedicated to Bare Salvation, and (ultimately) nothing-else-matters

This is a consequence of that strand of Reformation theology that focuses (almost exclusively) on Salvation by Faith - by the Grace of God. 

The Pure Protestant inference is that salvation is the only thing that matters, and salvation is achieved by faith in God during this mortal life - indeed specifically faith at the end of this mortal life

For a Pure Protestant: "As the tree falls, so shall it lie" - eternally. In other words, by the state of our soul at the moment of death, so shall our eternal destiny be decided.  


This has some appalling consequences in practice; because the whole of our mortal lives up to the moment of death is hazardous and futile at best.

The optimal thing in a mortal life would be to die at the instant of conversion; to eliminate the risk that subsequent experiences would cause us to backslide and lose faith*. 

Presumably; it is only the prohibition on suicide that prevents this being a normal post-conversion sequela - but anyway, a PP would be very likely to pray for the deliverance from the threat of damnation by wanting Death ASAP, for as long as he has faith.

 
What then should a Pure Protestant do with his life? 

Just about the only valid activities would seem to be - 1. to guard one's faith, and 2. to seek the conversion of others: evangelism. 

And this is, indeed, the tendency of Pure Protestants: faith is guarded by repeatedly re-visiting, re-living, re-experiencing the conversion experience; and by engaging in whatever evangelical activities are deemed (by current theological theories) to be likely to succeed at inducing the maximum number of conversions. 


That is the theory, or aspiration - yet (looking around at PP-tending churches as of 2025) it clearly does not work, and has not worked for some decades. 

The reasons is that with PP there is no such thing as legitimate positive, constructive, creative spiritual activity. 

And a faith-defending life spent under continuous, increasing, inescapable siege from the extreme and pervasive evil of modern Western societies can only lead to defeat - sooner or later. 


By denying the value of any this-worldly spiritual activity; Pure Protestantism creates a values-vacuum which is almost inevitably occupied by the hegemonic, secular, materialistic (and nowadays leftist) socio-political morality - which perhaps explains why self-identified Christians of this type are often strikingly successful in terms of status, money, and power. 

And this brings with it the besetting modern-Western sins such as untruthfulness, resentment and despair - and many (if not all) of the the characteristic value-inversions of totalitarianism

Holding-out against some of the inversions of the sexual revolution is one positive thing; but when Pure Protestantism eagerly embraces socialism, antiracism, climate-environmentalism, birdemic-healthism etc etc - then there is no cause whatsoever for self-congratulation.

Such churches have-been and are decisively assimilated into supporting the strategic demonic agenda.

   
The answer lies in examining the false assumptions at the root of Bare Salvationism. 

If God sustains us alive, then there is work he wants us to do; and that work must surely be spiritual in its nature and individual in its focus. 

It's up to each Pure Protestant to discover what that spiritual work must be for himself, personally, here-and-now. 


* That wonderful story in Acts of Philip and the Ethiopian eunuch, really ought to end (if Bare Salvationism was true, and if it were to have a genuinely joyful ending) with the eunuch slipping underwater and drowning, the instant after he was baptized... Rather than, as reported, going on his way "rejoicing". (And then, according to Ethiopian Orthodoxy - as I understand it - returning home to found the church in that country.)

3 comments:

Derek Ramsey said...

Speaking of despair, I noticed what when I stopped all voting I also generally stopped despairing (and not just about political matters)... or, at least, the tendency to despair was dramatically reduced if not completely eliminated. My participation—in what I now know to be an evil system—was what produced those feelings.

Voting is a quintessentially pro-Protestant ideal. You talk of churches that are "decisively assimilated into supporting the strategic demonic agenda." That's what I think.

Bruce Charlton said...

@Derek - For me it was when I was sacked from editing Medical Hypotheses in mid 2010, ostensibly because I refused to implement "peer review" - which is a kind of voting. At that point I stopped all voting, including committees. I had a similar benefit - but more a sense of greater clarity and simplicity of understanding. It seems to me that all systems of voting and the like, have a tendency to enmesh people in calculations of expediency that just go on and on, and soon push aside a true sense of values.

Bruce Charlton said...

@Derek - The deference to voting, as the best and only-proper way of making decisions, extends to obedience to church authority; since all churches nowadays seem to use voting as their ultimate mechanism for deciding upon "truth".

This gets justified by asserting (without any genuine conviction, I observe!) that God works by ensuring the vote-count turns-out to be true i.e. supposedly God works via "democracy" and committee mechanisms; and the individual Christian's duty is to obey... whatever voting currently tells him is the truth.

It is assumed that God has at some point made the decision that voting is the only Godly mechanism of decision making - and that, for example, a Monarch's (or any other individual person's) authority is intrinsically un-Godly, especially in modern conditions.