Why is the current Left (i.e. the post mid-1960s New Left) so dominant and powerful?
Since the mid-1960s the mainstream Left has transformed from its Old Left roots in communism and socialism, based on transformations of economic and social structures; to the new Left rooted in multiple, additive and fluid oppositions - anti-racism, feminism (anti-men), environmentalism (anti-CO2).
And throughout by the many-faceted sexual revolution evolving through anti-family, anti-monogamy, anti-marriage, anti biological sex and sexuality, and now pan-societal chosen subfertility and extinction.
How and why did this New Leftism swiftly so universally dominant that it overcame more than a century of Old Left socialism/ communism; and the New Left now includes and embraces all its mainstream would-be opposition ideologies such as Republican, Conservative, Libertarian, Nationalist* - even theocratic etc?
This is an important question because so many who oppose the Left try to emulate and exceed the Left's power by studying and copying its methods.
1. New Left is essentially oppositional.
2. New Left is therefore essentially destructive, not constructive.
The weakness of the Old Left was that it was partially constructive, indeed utopian - the communists and socialists all had a (more or less detailed) picture of some kind of future and stable ideal society towards which they purported to be working.
For example, a core ideology of the Old Left was economic equality - aiming therefore at a very highly equal "distribution" of income (especially), and also wealth (to vary degrees).
(But not power! The Old Left invariably centralized power, so that the revolutionary class could control everybody else for their own good!)
Another core objective of the Old Left was the imposition of public ownership of the means of production, usually by some version of nationalization or worker-control.
The New Left has long-since abandoned any such constructive notions: there is no ideal future society being aimed-at, no utopia.
Because it has all-but abandoned even the intent, even the pretence, of construction; it is therefore very easy for the New Left to change society by opposing and destroying whatever it currently deems to be bad.
Destructive change is vastly easier than constructive change, and when New Left is aimed-at a wide (and expanding) range of destructive changes; then destructive change of any thing the Lefts deems bad is perceived as an effective exercise of Left power.
*There is no such thing as The Right in modern mainstream politics. All parties and organizations are now of-the-Left. This includes churches.
In conclusion; the New Left is so powerful and has come to dominate the entirety of high-level institutional life in the West because it seeks and achieves destructive change; and destruction is quick and facile compared with construction.
And this is, of course, why those who desire to oppose the Left cannot use the methods of the Left
...Because using the methods of the New Left is necessarily to pursue the agenda of the New Left.
5 comments:
It's technology that strengthened the Left. Communications technology specifically, first television, now cheap surveillance tools. Their methods and skillset haven't changed but they're now able to operate at a scale never before possible. Television wasn't just more efficient, it was also a constant presence in the home, which made it directly accessible by women. It also bypassed what remained of the literacy barrier and unified the national culture.
Transportation technology, too. In the wake of the Bubonic Plague, the wages of the English peasant tripled, and London tried so hard to micromanage society into re-serfing them that the Peasants War happened. If London had been capable at the time of depressing those wages by importing a flood of new workers then England would never have had a middle class.
Technology enhanced Christianity, too. Most people claim Martin Luther was the founder of Protestantism, but I claim it was Gutenberg. Until the printing press decimated the cost of distributing Scripture, Christianity was easily gatekept by clergy resulting in institutional dependency. Afterwards, believers had the choice whether to trust clergy or Scripture directly.
@GQ - Restricting myself to the first para - "Their methods and skillset haven't changed" is just plain wrong from what I know.
I was a keen Old Left-ite in my teens, and came from a Trades Union family, joined the Labour Party on my 16th birthday etc. It seems undeniable that almost everything about that kind of socialism has not just been abandoned but (in the case of the primacy of native working class men) become demonized.
(It took a couple of years to for me to wise up - partially, but I do know this stuff from the inside.)
One major example is the change from equality of opportunity as ideal, to equality of outcome (i.e. quotas) - but with strategic institutional lying to pretend that the inequality of outcome is due to insidious inequality of opportunity. This can be seen in the shift from Old Left pro-eugenics and advocacy of IQ testing, to what we have now.
Since I am a Catholic and not a Protestant, I disagree with the commenter above that "technology enhanced Christianity", as I don't see Lutheranism as an "enhancement". But besides that, I do not think that literacy and easy distribution or printed material was necessarily better, at least in that sense, nor that it made people "think more for themselves". Most people are fine receiving their thoughts second-hand, and this happens even today, when they are supposedly all able to find "any information at their fongertips". I think that in some ways, an illiterate peasant from the Middle Ages was more able to think independently that most modern people glued to their cellphones all day.
It's not a Protestant-specific thing. Rome also benefited form the printing press relieving human drudgery and making Scripture more available to clergy. Were priests more effective when they had less access to reference materials? There's a big moral difference between people choosing to be ignorant, and people being forced by circumstance into ignorance... doubly so for the leaders of Church and society.
@GQ - For me the causal arrow goes in the opposite direction. I understand the (gradual, over several generations) development of varietis of Protestantism to be a consequence of inner changes in human consciousness; and the development of printing is an indirect consequence of the same inner change.
In other words; although there is of course a circularity of influence once the process is going; the *origin* of these changes is in changes of human consciousness - rather than the trigger being human consciousness passively responding to social changes (which is by far the usual model for explanation - and that which you seem to be using here).
Post a Comment