Thursday 7 June 2012

Italian fluency and German effort: Rossini and Weber


Rossini and Weber are both second rank composers who are both firmly in the operatic and orchestral repertoire - and both are on the 'light' side of classical music. Both are, let's say, about equal in quality.

I very much like them both. But which do I prefer? The answer is Weber.

Rossini is probably a better composer, in the sense that he is effortlessly fluent, a fount of melody, a sparkling orchestrator. He also wrote the one genuinely funny opera (Barber of Seville).

By contrast there is something lumbering about Weber, his music is all angles and effort. His one repertory opera - Der Freischutz - is the best romantic opera in the German tradition (which means it is the best of all) - and yet it contains no really first rate arias.

And yet. There is something fresh, genuine and earnest about Weber - something clean and honest - that is beyond Rossini.

In Rossini there is no friction - it all slides-past like greased lightning!

I find that I value Weber for the fact that he contains so much resistance which he must then effortfully overcome.

In the end, it is a temperamental thing: the two great European characters - Latin and Northern. My preference is firmly for the Nordic over the Mediterranean; for the forest over the beach. I am somewhat jealous, somewhat resentful of the Southern ease and comfort and style - but it does seem rather shallow, rather glib.



dearieme said...

A big 4WD, a/c full on, belting along the edge of an Australain salt lake under a scorching sun, and Rossini overtures blaring.


Bruce Charlton said...

@ Sounds a bit ike Sam Johnson's thing about bowling along in a coach with a pretty woman by your side - I presume Mrs Dearieme was seated to your left, or maybe driving so you could really enjoy the music and the view...

I do love Rossini BTW - the one and only classical LP we had as a child included the Overtures from Thieving Magpie and Barber of Seville, so I have a special affection for them; especially the former.

dearieme said...

Oh yes, my beautiful beloved was by my side.