Tuesday 30 July 2019

The nature of Sin in the Fourth Gospel: If Resurrection is the cure, then Sin is Mortality

WmJas has clarified for me that the phrase that Jesus was 'the Lamb of God', was a reference to the Passover feats, and its use of a male lamb's blood to avert death.

Thus, when (in the Fourth Gospel) John the Baptist calls Jesus the Lamb of God that takes away the sin of the world, he was not using sin to mean immorality (as we do nowadays). JtB intended sin to mean (something like) the condition of mortality.

Sin is about mortality, not morality.

We need an explanation that fits the cure Jesus was offering - eternal resurrected life - with the disease from which Man is suffering, ie. sin.

Rephrased: The true explanation of John's phrase must make sense of 'sin' in such a way such that life everlasting could be understood to cure it.


Question: Why and how would Men being resurrected cure the world of sin?

Answer: When sin means our mortal state, and all that entails - corruption, decay, disease, weakness as well as death - sin is (and is caused by) the impermanence and transitoriness of all things.

That was the sin of the world which Jesus came to take-away.


Francis Berger said...

Reading this post was akin to experiencing an epiphany - at least for me.

Bruce Charlton said...

@Francis - This interpretation does seem like that, I agree.

Of course, this is only made clear by focusing on the Fourth Gospel and regarding it as our primary authority. If we try to square this insight with the rest of the New Testament, that clarity will be blurred or lost. So, as always, assumptions are crucial to conclusions.

S.K. Orr said...

I second Francis's comment. This post is a bracing observation, and the little "Aha!" moments are so rare that they must be treasured.

Wm Jas Tychonievich said...

I agree with the other commenters. This is a crucial insight. I had never been able to deal with the idea of a vicarious sacrifice to take away someone else's moral guilt, and now I realize that that was never what Jesus was about.